They're Real! Xtreme Precision Liner - Wasserfester Eyeliner

Horrible. Acted as if it was dried out. Impossible to use.

Must skip

it was nice in the beginning but it dried out MUCH faster than any other of their products... so if you're looking for something that will be bold and last you a few weeks forget this product.

The best eyeliner i’ve used. I love the very very fine tip, it makes it super easy to apply. I’ve bought it 3 or 4 times and it never disappoints!

Not worth it for oily lids

Goes on SO nicely, but is definitely NOT smudge proof. It practically disappeared from my oily eyelids. Definitely returning.

I've had better drug store eyeliner that worked. sadly this was a disappointment, didn't stay on my oily eyelids, faded, transfered and smudged:(

Brown smudges badly !!

I am very disappointed in the brown eyeliner. I tried the black in store and it was amazing, but the brown is nothing like it. Within minutes it smudges. Application is great, but this is not waterproof or smudge free. Regretting this purchase and will not be using this eyeliner.

Not worth the money Bad product dry up fast really regret buying it

almost dry, so disappointing

I tried the tester at the store and loved it, bought it right away and opened it 2 weeks after and it was almost dry! No matter how much I shaked it... It is not a cheap product and it was very disappointing.

Skip this if you sweat or have oily skin

While i love the precision this offers it doesn’t matter because this will smudge and wipe off after wearing, especially if you sweat or have oily skin.

See through

Good for the first few times I used. About a week later, it started becoming see through. I would have to keep applying and it became a mess. I do not recommend

New fave!

Just purchased this liner again! I'm completely baffled by the bad reviews. Mine didn't dry up quickly, I used it for about 2 months very regularly. It has always gone on a beautiful, pigmented black. Maybe people don't shake it prior to application? I have normal, slightly oily skin and this liner stays put after a long day at work.

Would not buy again :(

It seemed dried out since day one. Barely any pigment and rubs off from itself. Would not buy again.