They're Real! Mini Mascara

Not a good product at all when I opened to use it was completely dried inside.

So much smudging and transfer!!

What a let down! Initially, this mascara goes on like a dream and looks great. An hour later, its smudged all over the place. I was so surprised by this as I definitely do not have oily skin- this never happens to me with other brands. I tried every technique I could think of to avoid this because I loved the mascara but nothing worked. It’s a throw away for me. Nothing more humbling than unknowingly walking around with giant raccoons eyes!!

when i first put in on i loved the lengthening it did. I went to an interview 10 minutes away from my house. when I got back in the car 45 minutes later there was SO much black under my eyes. I was so embarrassed. never had so much transfer from a mascara EVER. disappointed.

From fave to NEVER buy again

Like so many others, I’m disappointed in what used to be my favorite mascara. The formula must’ve changed - it transfers leaving me with raccoon eyes. I’m now looking for another brand.

Used for 10+ years, now it sucks

This used to be my go to since it came out over 10 years ago- I’d try samples of others but nothing came close. Now unfortunately the formula is different and I get transfer around my lower eye every single time I wear it. It goes on clumpy and is impossible to wash off at the end of the day. Scrambling to find an alternative.

Very irritating to the eyes

This has to be the worst mascara I’ve ever used and I’ve been using mascaras for half my adult life. When you first it - it looks amazing but you have atmost 2-3 hours before it will irritate your eyes and leave you looking like a raccoon. And it doesn’t stop, even after I’ve completed cleansed and removed the product it will continue to irritate them until I have to really splash them and cool them with a cold water towel.

My favorite!!

I’ve been ride or die for this mascara for the past probably 10 years. I’ve tried other brands but I always come back to benefit! I naturally have really long lashes, but this really helps define them. 

Nope. No. Nope.

I used to swear by this stuff! Like, got all my friends hooked too. But the formula has changed and this is one of the worst mascaras anywhere. It clumps on application, then crumbles and flakes all day, leaving me with racoon eyes. I had hoped it was a bad batch but no, this is not the same product it used to be. AVOID!

An Absolute No!!

This is hands down one of the absolute WORST mascaras I’ve ever used. This mascara bleeds and runs constantly, even if you don’t sweat at all. It’s horrendous; and embarrassing! Do not buy unless you’re wanting to look like a raccoon with mascara smudging around your eyes!

works just as intended

This product is aptly named. i have naturally long lashes & whenever I wear this mascara, someone will all of I'm wearing false lashes. mascara dries well, no clumping, and of course adds good length. my 2nd favorite mascara behind lambcome Monsieur big.

Not the same - transfers to undereye

I rarely leave reviews but I'm so disappointed. This has been my go to mascara for at least the past 8 years and in the past year I've noticed transfer to my under eyes. Did a quick google and apparently it's not just me - dozens of reviews now noting the same. Don't know why they ruined a good thing but can no longer recommend!

Makes my eyelashes so long without even curling

Everyone keeps asking me if I’m wearing false eyelashes even got told that my eyelashes look so pretty it’s distracting the only reason I didn’t put 5 stars is because the mascara does run after a few hours and I look like a raccoon.