They're Real! Mini Mascara

Super thin, made my lashes fall out. Not really lengthening or voluminous, much better products out there i hate it. can’t do multiple layers or it’ll look like a spider

WHAT HAPPENED??

This was my go-to mascara for years. However, I randomly convince myself I need to find a lesser expensive option. I took a break from it, but inevitably ended up going back… but this isn’t it. Every time I look in a mirror I have black smudges all around my eyes, and the irritation - so so bad! Beyond disappointing. It used to be great. Now it’s terrible.

Awesome beauty

A must have for any occasion, so lengthening and natural looking.

My go to mascara

Love this - great for length. Rich dark black, smooth application, not super wet. I love how the brush fans out my lashes but of course. Easy to use, but obviously application technique matters.

10 years of usage to never again

I had been using this mascara, like a lot of other folks, for over 10 years. From prom, graduation, and everyday makeup- tried and true, I loved it! Since the formula changed a little while ago now I will not be repurchasing again. It left a lot of smudging and completely transferred to the top and bottom of my eyes. I have very hooded eyes, so finding a mascara that does not smudge is really important- and sadly, this one now smudges a lot.

Semi Sold

I love the length and boldness, not the staying power. Did not survive my workout.

Ehhh

This mascara didn’t old a curl that well, and weighed down my lashes. The worst quality of this was the flaking and smudging. Very similar to the roller lash mascara.

Not a good product at all when I opened to use it was completely dried inside.

So much smudging and transfer!!

What a let down! Initially, this mascara goes on like a dream and looks great. An hour later, its smudged all over the place. I was so surprised by this as I definitely do not have oily skin- this never happens to me with other brands. I tried every technique I could think of to avoid this because I loved the mascara but nothing worked. It’s a throw away for me. Nothing more humbling than unknowingly walking around with giant raccoons eyes!!

when i first put in on i loved the lengthening it did. I went to an interview 10 minutes away from my house. when I got back in the car 45 minutes later there was SO much black under my eyes. I was so embarrassed. never had so much transfer from a mascara EVER. disappointed.

From fave to NEVER buy again

Like so many others, I’m disappointed in what used to be my favorite mascara. The formula must’ve changed - it transfers leaving me with raccoon eyes. I’m now looking for another brand.

Used for 10+ years, now it sucks

This used to be my go to since it came out over 10 years ago- I’d try samples of others but nothing came close. Now unfortunately the formula is different and I get transfer around my lower eye every single time I wear it. It goes on clumpy and is impossible to wash off at the end of the day. Scrambling to find an alternative.