Smoky Lash - Mascara

I wanted to really love this mascara. I found the formula to be very dry and hard to work with; you have to be quick when layering mascara, it was impossible with this.

The Perfect Mascara

Hands down, my fave. Best quality and value out there. Gives great volume and the brush is awesome. Thick, black lashes and washes off well too. My go-to.

Not worth the price

I think I ended up returning this one. I only bought it this one time. Definitely not water resistant. Not special enough of a look either.

I have loved this mascara since my 1st taste of high end products. I love that it gives me this smoldering black lush lashes that have volume and a bit of length. I love the brush and everything about it. I hate that MUFE isn't as hot of brand as it once was as this product can't be found in store anymore. It's a legend mascara for me who has short whimpy kid lashes.

This review is for my most recent tube of this mascara. I ordered it online and was sent a tube that was so old and dry, it was unusable! I had to throw it away! I usually jettison my own mascara far before it gets to the condition that the tube I received was in. A big disappointment as I normally love this mascara.

One of my favorite mascaras!

This is one of my favorite mascaras! I always get compliments on my lashes whenever I use it! Makes my lashes look longer and fuller! Would definitely recommend this!

Not as Green as I would like

Bought the green thinking it would look appear green/hunter green however could not tell much of a different than a dull black.

Honestly wish I could love this mascara but...

This mascara just did not work for me. It did give me volume to my lashes but I look very clumpy and feel very heavy and uncomfortable.. my eye got really sensitive after a few minutes of wearing this. Overall I don't think I will be trying this mascara again.

Great

This is the best mascara on the market I have used it for years. 1 depends and instant thick long lashes. And it doesn’t smudge and transfer or cause raccoon eyes

BLU-IZE

Beautiful shade of blue; really make blue eyes pop! Goes on easy, no flaking. Love it (have the green, too, also a beautiful shade!)

I’m a huge fan of the make up forever brand. Unfortunately, this mascara left my eyes overloaded with wet, sticky goop that dried into large clumps. I tried cleaning the brush hoping this was the issue and I only applied one coat. It was no use. Sadly, I’ve had to look elsewhere for my lash needs.

Love/Hate

I have really mixed feeling about this mascara. My first feelings are that it is MAGIC!! I have fairly straight lashes that do not take kindly to curling, but this shtuff curls them like a dream! Without an eyelash curler! And they look fuller, longer, better; all without being spidery! It really does everything you want a mascara to do. And the brown is not black brown. deepest brown, brown black, or whatever nearly black colors most mascaras are. Its legit brown! Looks so good! Now, my other feelings about it is that after about 4 to 6 months it just... goes to heck in a hand basket. First it gets clumpy. No probs, heat the bottle under warm running water. applies like a dream again! but then after it dries it just falls off. Fall out all over your face, clothes, and eyeballs. And there's still so much more product! you don't want to throw it away! it was expensive and you're still in love! But no. Throw it out. Then tell Make Up For Ever that they need to rethink this formula because they are so stinking close to perfection! SO CLOSE. I'm probably going to buy one this weekend because when it's good it is SO good!