Smooth Silk Eye Pencil

The perfect deep purple to accentuate green or hazel eyes without being obvious. Goes on like silk - absolutely no resistance. I appreciate the smudge end for softening the line without the need to hunt for a cotton swab.

Glides beautifully over the lid and the colour enhances anyone with hazel or green eys. Stays put and long lasting.

Does not stay on

Beautiful pencil, goes on smoothly, not worth the money. This did not stay on. Not long wearing at all, but a typical eye pencil with a good smudge. I’d say it’s good for the waterline, but did not last on me at all. I don’t even grab for it for evening because I’m afraid it will end up on my lid or below my eye.

terrible!!!

terrible eye pencil! seriously unbelievable how disappointing this was. it's dry, doesn't go on the lid smoothly and its not rich in color. and the small amount of color you do get fades withing a few hours.

Thoroughly Pleased!!! Best eyeliner ever!!!

This is the best eyeliner that I’ve ever tried and I only have to place one line on. Goes on very very smoothly and stays on all day.

Perfection!!!

Favorite eyeliner. Goes on easily without tugging. Stays on all day (combination skin), doesn’t irritate eyes. Safe ingredients. Thank you Giorgio Armani and Sephora!!!

This is a great eyeliner- it applies very smoothly, without skipping, tugging, or pulling. Long-wearing as well, without smudging, transferring, or fading. Color payoff is excellent, very rich- excellent black eyeliner.

Love this eyeliner

Love this eyeliner and the foam tip is perfect for a smoky eye.

I have repurchased this eyeliner at least a dozen times. This is the only liner that lasts in my waterline all day. Not only does it last all day, it doesn't smudge and it's soft. I can't recommend it enough. If you are looking for a pencil liner, this is it.

Purple allergen?

I have long loved these eyeliners -- smooth and easy going on. This time, though, the purple color is giving me an allergic reaction -- must have been a change in formula. Green still fine!

Best eyeliner for tightlining!!!

I honestly don't know why the negative smudging reviews, for me this eyeliner is amazing! I only use this pencil for tightlining my upper waterline and I have tried a lot of eyeliners... UD, MUFE wp pencils, Marc Jacobs Highliners, Stila, Nars Larger Than Life... etc etc and all of them smudges on me by the end of the day, some stamps onto my lower waterline almost immediately (I'm looking at you UD). This GA one out performs them all!!! I don't even have to wait and blink immediately and it stays where I wants it all day for a good 10 hours. That being said, I don't use this eyeliner to line my upper lash line. This pencil is way too soft and creamy that it's hard to do a perfect line. This pencil deposits a lot of product (super opaque matte true back line) in one swipe so the tip gets worn down very fast, and if you apply too much pressure you'll end up having a lot of product stuck around the root of your lashes, maybe that's why it smudges for others. This is a great pencil for using it for smudging purposes to do a smoky eye (that's why the smudge sponge tip) or even a black eyelid base. I would not recommend this for precise sharp lining. FYI, I have extremely sensitive eyes and they irritates and turn red very easily. My eyes are also always watery due to allergies, long hours of staring into 4 monitors at work on a daily basis, and wind blowing into them. This pencil neither irritates nor budge on my eyes, and it washes off very easily too (I use shu uemura cleansing oil blanc chroma).

Awesome!!

This is by far the best eyeliner pencil I have ever used. It's so creamy and pigmented, and the smudger works amazing too. I normally use a liquid liner for my upper lash line but I use this pencil at my lower lash line and blend it out with the smudger and it looks amazing on me.