Always On - Eyeliner

not even close

Didn’t even last 8 hours let alone the advertised 24. I was not subject to any harsh environments, no sweat, not very oily. No idea.

Excellent with a primer. Not so good without one

This eyeliner is excellent with a primer (I use the urban decay eye primer). With the primer, it will not budge through sweating on the dance floor, allergy eye watering, and (I’m not proud of this) sleeping in it. I’ve put it through all that and it still looks fantastic. HOWEVER without a primer is fades and starts to flake off within a couple of hours. It really doesn’t last at all. So if you tend to wear a primer, I completely recommend this eyeliner. But if you tend to forgo a primer, or you would like the option to skip it, this is not the liner for you.

Smashbox what happened?

I have used this product for at least 6 years steady and the past year when I reorder the quality has become very disappointing. The product transfers onto my lid and smears easily after only about an hour or so of wear. This is not the same product that I had grown to trust. What happened? I have started buying drugstore eyeliner again after this which doesn't make me look like I've been crying in a chimney.

disappointing

I bought it in stores like a two weeks ago and It’s already running out, it smudges and it’s not that waterproof, my eyes water a lot and when they do the eyeliner already halfway off. Not worth the price.

Usually Buy Stila

I liked the idea of having to only buy the refills, less waste; however, the tip on this one is hard compared to Stila’s or even the Sephora brand. I’ll stick with what I know is good next time.

Black Eyeliner

This is amazing eyeliner it stays for 24hr and deep black

The New Formula is Terrible

What happened to this product??? I got a replacement for the one I’ve had for two years Bc it finally started to dry out and the formula is nothing like it used to be. It’s no longer a true black and it’s easily rubbed off. Need to apply layers to get decent pigment but the tip rubs off the layer of liner you put on before. Not waterproof. Very disappointed Bc this used to be the best eyeliner I’d ever had and now it’s worse than the stuff at the dollar store.

the liner doesn't last long once it is on, not pigmented at all!

The felt tip sucks at retaining the product, the application is a nightmare. Don’t waste your money

Sehr enttäuschend

Hab mir aufgrund der positiven Bewertungen den Eyeliner bestellt und bin wahnsinnig enttäuscht. Für den Preis erwarte ich mir definitiv eine bessere Haltbarkeit. Ein paar Stunden ist das absolute Maximum für diesen hier. Absolut keine Kaufempfehlung!

Has Potential

Works better on my hand... Dry out of the box Too dry to create a decent line, applies patchy. Will be returning and looking for something else.

What happened?

The recent reviews make sense of my experience. This was my favorite eyeliner. My last couple of purchases dried out very quickly ... I thought maybe it was just product that had been sitting in a warehouse too long during the pandemic. But a lot of other users are having the same problem, which is more of a trend. Really sad, because I loved this liner.